Two Minute Tips

Getting the unemployment story right

September 8, 2014

Share this article:

By Flickr user ProgressOhio

Homey is back from vacation with the same mandate. As Yoda would say, “Butt, I will kick. Names, I will take.”

As I write the unemployment report for August has come out. At all too many places, the emphasis will be placed on the unemployment rate, which fell 0.1 percentage point to 6.1 percent. The story might note that the 142,000 jobs added are below the 200,000 that economists expected. And that’s pretty much it.

So I want to burn your newspaper and un-bookmark your worthless website.

With the huge job losses of the Great Recession and weak job creation of the recovery, and most new jobs paying far less than those lost, unemployment is one of the biggest stories. Your editors may be sick of it. Readers are not. At least if you do your job.

Some essentials.

1. The “official” unemployment rate requires context. As this chart shows, it is at a level higher than any similar point in a recovery since data began being collected in the late 1940s. So unemployment remains very high. In the past, this 6.1 percent rate would have been considered a crisis.

2. The Bureau of Labor Statistics has several measures. The most important is the U-6 unemployment rate, which includes discouraged workers and those in part-time jobs who want full-time work. The U-6 in August was 12 percent.

3. Context is also critical for the number of net new jobs created. It takes about 125,000 jobs per month just to keep up with the natural growth of the labor force.

4. The vast job losses of the recession and weak recovery have created a persistent “jobs gap.” Your guide here is the Hamilton Project’s Jobs Gap calculator. For example, if the economy continued to grind out 142,000 jobs per month, it would take until nearly 2020 to make up the losses of the Great Recession. This should be in every story.

 5. You can adjust this FRED chart of total non-farm employment to show percent change from a year ago. The result is staggering. Among other things, it shows that job recoveries have been getting weaker since the 1990s.

6. A persistent issue is labor force participation. In August, it fell to 62.8 percent, although that has been fairly stable for the past year. Still, it is the lowest we’ve seen since the 1970s. Some of this is explained by retiring boomers. But there’s also an element of people unable to find work. The monthly JOLTS shows that two job-seekers are chasing every open position.

7. August’s report showed wage growth of 2 percent, where it’s been stuck for years. This tells us that wages remain weak and are not an inflation risk. You can dig into hours worked, too. Are they rising or falling?

8. You can and should slice the data by ethnic, gender and age groups. And make comparisons with other OECD countries. Here’s how Bloomberg showed the critical issue of lack of jobs for prime-age workers.

9. Your state, county and metro data typically come later and have less information. But press the state labor economist or a labor market expert on these issues. The Brookings Institution’s MetroMonitor provides several datapoints for the 100 largest metros, albeit trailing the latest releases.

10. Do mention the sectors that are gaining jobs, but make sure you have some comparisons over time. And dig into the sectors that continue to lose jobs. For example, federal austerity and job losses are a major headwind against recovery. Ronald Reagan aggressively added civilian federal jobs to boost the recovery in the early 1980s. President Obama and the conservative-dominated Congress have not.

As always, one month doesn’t represent a trend. Make sure you are looking at the previous three- and six-month performance. Using some or all of these tips will make your story much more compelling and accurate.

More Like This...

Two Minute Tips

Sign up now.
Get one Tuesday.

Every Tuesday we send out a quick-read email with tips for business journalism.

Subscribers also get access to the Tip archive.

Get Two Minute Tips For Business Journalism Delivered To Your Email Every Tuesday

Two Minute Tips

Every Tuesday we send out a quick-read email with tips for business journalism. Sign up now and get one Tuesday.

Our New Look
The Reynolds Center for Business Journalism is starting 2023 with a new look that we hope better illustrates our core mission to provide accurate and authoritative resources about business journalism, in order to help both reporters and news consumers understand the importance of business news and to demystify the sometimes arcane topics it covers.
Businesses, markets, and economies move in cycles – ups and downs – which is why our new logo contains a “candlestick” chart representing increases as well as downturns, and serves as a reminder that volatility is an unavoidable attribute of modern life. But it’s also possible to prepare for volatility by being well informed, and informing the general public to help level the information playing field is the primary goal of business journalism. The Reynolds Center is committed to supporting that goal, which is why the candlestick pattern in our logo merges directly into the name of our founding sponsor, Donald W. Reynolds.
Our new logo comes with a shorter name. Business is borderless, and understanding the global links in supply chains, trade, and flows of funds and people is essential to make sense of our fast-paced, globalized world. So we’re dropping the word “National” from our name and will aim to provide content that is applicable to business news globally.
We hope you like the new look. Best wishes for 2023!