Two Minute Tips

Localizing the new NAFTA goals

August 1, 2017

Share this article:

Understand the new NAFTA goals, then localize them for your readers. ("Ships on the Galveston Harbour" by "Marcus" via Flickr, CC BY-SA 2.0)
Understand the new NAFTA goals, then localize them for your readers. ("Ships on the Galveston Harbour" by "Marcus" via Flickr, CC BY-SA 2.0)

The office of the U.S. Trade Representative released a 17-page document in July outlining the Trump administration’s goals for renegotiations of NAFTA, the North American Free Trade Agreement.

During election season, candidate Trump frequently targeted the 1994 pact, which reduces or eliminates tariffs on most goods between the U.S., Canada and Mexico. He made frequent calls to renegotiate or even eliminate the deal in order to reduce the trade deficit and restore power to American workers. This, despite the consensus that NAFTA was generally good for the U.S. economy and did not adversely impact most workers in a significant way.

A few days into his administration, Trump made good on his promise to withdraw from the spiritually similar Trans Pacific Partnership. That agreement also sought regulatory consistency on environmental and labor issues. It also included a controversial provision allowing private investors to sue foreign governments for trade violations.

This is why it is surprising that many of the new goals for NAFTA renegotiation—which can technically get underway this month but is not expected until much later—resemble aspects of the TPP. They have earned criticism from protectionists on both sides of the aisle. President Trump is using his fast-track authority to negotiate the agreement before seeking congressional approval. President Barack Obama used the same authority to hash out TPP.

So what does it say?

The NAFTA goals have drawn the most vociferous criticism for being vague. But the details that are available make it clear the Trump administration would like to see a few updates to reflect the information age. It calls for new rules to ensure free digital trade as well as services in finance and telecommunications.

Though Trump never went as far as to declare China a currency manipulator, the document calls for a rule forbidding NAFTA countries from manipulating exchange rates to facilitate exports.

The TPP comparisons largely come from sections calling for transnational regulatory compliance and consistency in labor, intellectual property and environmental matters. Those were big aspects of the TPP.

It also calls for the elimination of various trade barriers on U.S. agricultural exports, a frequent point of contention with Canada.

What the goals don’t include are any threats to impose tariffs on American manufacturers who move production across the border, or any increased tariffs on goods from other NAFTA countries. That had been a favorite Trump theme that moved some critics to warn of a potential trade war.

Bringing it home

A lot of the document’s details are highly technical, and a lot of the technical points lack detail. But business journalists can get plenty out of it by focusing on how these changes to NAFTA might affect their states.

Look at which states are the most reliant on foreign trade. The Brookings Institute has a handy guide on the dependence of various states on Canada-U.S.-Mexico trade of intermediate goods. It also examines how major overhauls to international trade deals could impact individual metro areas.

These data show the states that do the most significant import business with NAFTA countries, and therefore the ones that would be most impacted by significant changes to the trade deal. Understanding the biggest industries in your state will also help you identify specific provisions in the renegotiations that would have the biggest impact. For example, a business reporter for the Detroit Free Press would seek out any potential changes to the auto industry.

Many states do a brisk export business with NAFTA countries as well. This CNN Money story employs Census data to show that many of the country’s most populous states would be heavily impacted by big NAFTA changes. The Bureau of Labor Statistics identifies the biggest industry in each state and how each has changed over time. And remember, just because an industry isn’t directly involved in trade doesn’t mean it won’t be affected.

Reporter’s Takeaway

• The new goals call for TPP-like regulatory provisions, enhanced U.S. agricultural exports and a reduction of the trade deficit

• Localize this and give it context by focusing on how much international trade your state does and in what sectors. Offices of economic development, the U.S. Census Bureau and the Bureau of Economic Analysis can all help you with these data.

More Like This...

Ways to approach SNAP locally

Income inequality and food insecurity have been a long-standing issue not only for the campaign trail, but for many Americans. In 2018, 11.1% of households were determined as “food insecure,”

FOIA user’s guide: Six key sources

When a city bids to host the Olympics, it’s big sports news. It’s also a massive business story. Billions are invested, which means companies will vie for it and taxpayers often

Two Minute Tips

Sign up now.
Get one Tuesday.

Every Tuesday we send out a quick-read email with tips for business journalism.

Subscribers also get access to the Tip archive.

Get Two Minute Tips For Business Journalism Delivered To Your Email Every Tuesday

Two Minute Tips

Every Tuesday we send out a quick-read email with tips for business journalism. Sign up now and get one Tuesday.

Our New Look
The Reynolds Center for Business Journalism is starting 2023 with a new look that we hope better illustrates our core mission to provide accurate and authoritative resources about business journalism, in order to help both reporters and news consumers understand the importance of business news and to demystify the sometimes arcane topics it covers.
Businesses, markets, and economies move in cycles – ups and downs – which is why our new logo contains a “candlestick” chart representing increases as well as downturns, and serves as a reminder that volatility is an unavoidable attribute of modern life. But it’s also possible to prepare for volatility by being well informed, and informing the general public to help level the information playing field is the primary goal of business journalism. The Reynolds Center is committed to supporting that goal, which is why the candlestick pattern in our logo merges directly into the name of our founding sponsor, Donald W. Reynolds.
Our new logo comes with a shorter name. Business is borderless, and understanding the global links in supply chains, trade, and flows of funds and people is essential to make sense of our fast-paced, globalized world. So we’re dropping the word “National” from our name and will aim to provide content that is applicable to business news globally.
We hope you like the new look. Best wishes for 2023!