California has invested in expanding psychiatric treatment, but an investigation by the San Francisco Chronicle found that some for-profit psychiatric hospitals were understaffed, spending less on direct patient care and facing repeated reports of abuse and deficient treatment.
For investigative reporters Cynthia Dizikes and Joaquin Palomino, the investigation began with an anonymous tip from a former patient who described being involuntarily committed to a for-profit psychiatric facility more than 100 miles from home. His account led the reporters to examine whether his experience reflected deeper failures in California’s mental health system.
Beginning in 2025, the Failed to Death investigative series examined hospital inspection records, staffing data and corporate finances. The reporting found that for-profit psychiatric hospitals spent less than half as much on direct patient care per patient than comparable non-profit facilities and psychiatric units in general hospitals.
In an interview with The Reynolds Center, Dizikes and Palomino discussed how the team moved from a single patient’s account to an investigation into hospital finances, regulatory gaps and patient safety.
When a patient’s account revealed a broader problem
After the investigation began with a former patient’s account, the reporters wanted to determine whether the experience was evidence of a larger problem. The timing raised additional questions as the state was planning to invest more in psychiatric facilities and expand voluntary treatment. The reporters wanted to understand whether existing hospitals were equipped to provide safe care for patients.
“We knew that, at the moment in which we were becoming aware of these wide systemic problems in the system as it existed, the state was also planning on expanding them,” Dizikes explained.
The reporters examined deficiency reports issued by the California Department of Public Health and federal regulators. What they found suggested a pattern of patient safety problems that extended beyond isolated cases.
“We were sort of immediately taken back by some of the harm that was described in these reports,” Dizikes recalled.
According to Palomino, the investigation found that these facilities employed fewer workers per patient and relied on unlicensed staff, including mental health technicians and mental health workers. These positions are often entry-level jobs that do not require specialized mental health training or certification, with wages as low as $20 an hour.
Enforcing staffing requirements
After the initial stories were published, lawmakers demanded answers and the state’s Senate Health Committee chair acknowledged the failures at a March 2025 hearing saying, “As the state of California we have failed. People have died under our watch.” In response, Gov. Gavin Newsom declared a public emergency and signed legislation addressing minimum staffing standards at psychiatric hospitals. State officials also began investigating the assaults and deaths uncovered by the Chronicle.
The new emergency staffing regulations, which took effect on June 1, 2026, established minimum nurse-to-patient patios at freestanding acute psychiatric hospitals. The requirements include one licensed nurse for every six adult patients and one for every five patients under the age of 18. Hospitals must also maintain these ratios continuously rather than averaging staffing levels over an entire shift.
By December 2025, the California Department of Public Health had imposed nearly $1.8 million in penalties against four for-profit psychiatric hospitals in connection with the Chronicle’s reporting. That was about six times the amount against all of the state’s for-profit psychiatric hospitals combined during the previous six years.
Keeping attention on patient safety
The investigation’s impact extended beyond the regulatory domain. For the reporters, hearing from patients, families and hospital workers who felt their experiences had finally been acknowledged was another important outcome.
Former patients and relatives told the journalist that they felt heard, while workers welcomed the prospect of staffing standards that can improve the conditions.
Given that Dizikes and Palomino were investigating psychiatric care for those who are the most vulnerable, they made a conscious effort to go slowly and work transparently with everyone they encountered, especially when it came to patients deciding if they want their voices recorded for posterity.
“It’s always a challenge in this line of work when you’re dealing with people who’ve experienced immense loss, or have been through something very traumatic,” said Palomino. He said it’s important for reporters to be honest about what the reporting process looks like and how the projects can take a lot of time.
Throughout the course of reporting, Palomino said it’s important to continuously check in with their sources because it helps to fact-check with them and build a long-term relationship.
Dizikes reflected on their responsibility involved in reporting on people who had experienced trauma or loss.
“You go on this really long journey with people, and they put a lot of trust in you,” she said. Seeing people feel that their circumstances had improved, gave the work its greatest meaning.






