Two Minute Tips

How to stop astroturfing by special interests

February 22, 2018

Share this article:

Astroturfing refers to the attempts by political or business groups to create a false impression of grassroots support for some position. (Photo via Pixabay.com)

One of the covert ways that companies and PR firms affect coverage and influence the public is through astroturfing.

Astroturf, as you probably know, is a type of artificial grass used in professional sports as a playing surface. Astroturfing, on the other hand, is the attempt by a political or business group to create a false impression of grassroots support for some position.

Fake non-partisan groups

I extend the definition to front groups secretly funded by organizations that wish to promote their interests. The intent is to create an apparently impartial third party that coincidentally happens to deliver statistics and talking points to reinforce the position of the sponsors. There was even a case of a lobbying firm pretending to be the NAACP, as Business Insider mentioned years ago.

It’s far more common than you might realize. There are PR consultancies that make a regular business of creating front groups to push the agendas of their clients, whether that is support of legislation favoring a given industry or opposition to such government actions as higher minimum wage levels or environmental regulation.

Social media fakery

In the social media world there are so-called bots, coordinated online accounts, and manufactured viral content that can help push a given view. The material may come through specialty PR firms to make tracing the connections more difficult.

They’ve been used widely in politics, but as the Guardian reported, the corporate world has taken to “persona management software” to create the social network impression of real individuals that instead are manufactured personalities, with names and email addresses.

Steps you can take

Knowing manipulation is rampant, and that it can come from all sides, is the first step to more careful reporting. Here are some others:

  • If you hear from an organization, look at its funding. Even non-profits, the preferred structure for astroturf groups, file tax forms. Check their filed IRS Form 990s, typically available through non-profit research sites like CharityWatch.org or GuideStar.org. Often you can find either major sources of funds or major recipients that will tie a group to some other organization. Also ask about the funding. When the organization or PR firm states that its backers names are private, be careful.
  • Email due diligence can perform wonders. The Wall Street Journal used email routing information to track a “viral” video attacking Al Gore’s An Inconvenient Truth to a D.C. lobbying group with a major petroleum client. I once tripped up someone working for a front group, who insisted that I had no basis for the statement, when he emailed me from his PR firm account.
  • Look for connections between people. Groups may hide funding sources and use fake online identities, but eventually you can find people who work for them. Some web and database searches should turn up some work histories. A previous connection to a company with interests in a given issue or to a PR firm isn’t a guarantee of something shady, but it can help you bring a skeptical and clear eye when considering the person as a potential source.

More Like This...

The clock is ticking: Deadline for entries to the 2017 Barlett & Steele Awards is this Monday, July 31. (Image from Photoshot via Pixabay, CCO Public Domain)

The stakeholders of daylight saving time

On Nov. 1, households across the country will participate in two national rituals: taking down Halloween decorations, and, more urgently, setting their clocks back by an hour.  The biannual switch

Localizing the fight over gig economy legislation

Assembly Bill 5 (AB5) went into effect in California on January 1 amid much controversy. The bill was designed to combat worker misclassification and provide greater labor protections to gig

Two Minute Tips

Sign up now.
Get one Tuesday.

Every Tuesday we send out a quick-read email with tips for business journalism.

Subscribers also get access to the Tip archive.

Get Two Minute Tips For Business Journalism Delivered To Your Email Every Tuesday

Two Minute Tips

Every Tuesday we send out a quick-read email with tips for business journalism. Sign up now and get one Tuesday.

Our New Look
The Reynolds Center for Business Journalism is starting 2023 with a new look that we hope better illustrates our core mission to provide accurate and authoritative resources about business journalism, in order to help both reporters and news consumers understand the importance of business news and to demystify the sometimes arcane topics it covers.
Businesses, markets, and economies move in cycles – ups and downs – which is why our new logo contains a “candlestick” chart representing increases as well as downturns, and serves as a reminder that volatility is an unavoidable attribute of modern life. But it’s also possible to prepare for volatility by being well informed, and informing the general public to help level the information playing field is the primary goal of business journalism. The Reynolds Center is committed to supporting that goal, which is why the candlestick pattern in our logo merges directly into the name of our founding sponsor, Donald W. Reynolds.
Our new logo comes with a shorter name. Business is borderless, and understanding the global links in supply chains, trade, and flows of funds and people is essential to make sense of our fast-paced, globalized world. So we’re dropping the word “National” from our name and will aim to provide content that is applicable to business news globally.
We hope you like the new look. Best wishes for 2023!